I have been trying to use epoxy for a deep finish on turned pieces. I think I finally succeeded. I used 30 minute epoxy and I used a technique that turned the piece on my lathe at or near 10 RPM. This kept the epoxy in motion to smooth out as it dried and gave the piece a thick glass like look. I liked the results.  However, when I asked my wife and others, their reaction was NO.  As my wife put it, "it makes it look artificial or plastic" I have to admit, she does have a valid point. I do like it because it does showcase the beautiful wood. You can compare this one with others in the background. What do you think?

 

I would say it depends entirely on the intended audience and end use of the object.  I don't dislike the finish as represented in your photo.  I've used epoxy as a finish on certain items I've made.  This choice was mainly thoughts toward durability as a utility finish.  The "reverse" bench dog below has a 30 minute epoxy finish and has held up well.  

 

 

On the other hand, I wouldn't use that finish on a bowl.  One reason is...I'm too lazy.  Burnished oil and wax are quick, easy, inexpensive, and food safe. 

 

As a suggestion and just to compare on the next batch of ornaments try some rattle can lacquer...just to see how the Mrs reacts.  In the grand scheme of things, it's your project and you can finish it however you see fit.  

 

.40

I agree with you and I do like to let the wood beauty shine on its own without the help of epoxy. I certainly did learn a. lot setting this up and it was the kind of fun that I'm sure you understand.  If all my fun experiments were in one barrel, I'm sure ti would full it to the top. Your bowl looks great! I would never attempt to use epoxy on a large piece, I'm sure it wold NOT work well or  look good.

 The biggest reason I chose this piece is that I found it after it fell from my Red Elm tree. When I was raking I noticed the end grain looked interesting. As I turned it, I saw that it needed reinforcing........thus Epoxy came to mind.

I can understand both arguments glass-like vs natural. As @forty_caliber said, the use and intended audience often dictates the type of finish.

 

I like the slow rotation idea for applying a finish. My lathe's slowest speed is 38 rpm. If the turning is to be glossy, I apply wipe on poly, with a brush, while the lathe is turning. No runs! 

The process of using a step motor to get that slow overwhelms me and precludes my use of that type product. As to shine I do think that is good for ornaments but do not think I want it on bowls.